Population biologists turn to pre-publication server to gain wider readership and rapid review of results.
The preprint server arXiv.org is perhaps best known as the preserve
of theoretical physicists and astrophysicists. But 2008 saw an influx of
submissions of unpublished manuscripts, or preprints, by
condensed-matter physicists who wanted to stake claims to the
fast-moving subject of iron-based superconductors called pnictides. Now
the life sciences may be on the cusp of their own ‘pnictide moment’,
with population geneticists leading the charge.
In the past month, leading research groups have posted to arXiv high-profile papers on the genetic history of southern Africans1 and Europeans2.
Other prominent population geneticists have submitted methods-based
papers to the server, which is hosted by Cornell University in Ithaca,
New York. The number of biology papers on the server is still small in
comparison with physical-sciences preprints (see ‘Biology opens up’), but Paul Ginsparg, a theoretical physicist at Cornell who founded arXiv in 1991 (ref. 3), welcomes what he hopes could be a sea change.
“It’s wonderful if biologists are belatedly joining the
late twentieth century,” he quips. “Welcome to the party; better late
Another attention-grabbing submission by prominent geneticists, posted
on 23 July, compares genomic variation in 22 African populations to
suggest an ancient genetic link between people in southern and eastern
One of the paper’s senior authors, geneticist David Reich of Harvard
Medical School in Boston, Massachusetts, publishes routinely in Nature and the Public Library of Science journals,
and co-author Carlos Bustamante, of Stanford University School of
Medicine in California, is a leader in the field. Reich says that first
author Joseph Pickrell, also at Harvard Medical School, suggested using
arXiv. Reich and the other co-authors saw no good reason not to post the
manuscript there. “It could be an example of the younger generation
coming in and finding this sort of thing natural,” says Ginsparg....